You are viewing a read-only archive of the site that used to be symbii.com, which was active from 2005–2013
Bogey Central Easter Egg
niraj.com
A Niraj
Sanghvi
Website


Something You Might Be Interested In
A collection of funny, interesting, and crazy stories you might be interested in
   
Is the new ask.com a real Google threat? Internet - Ask
I saw a story over at Search Engine Watch Blog about ask.com's rebranding campaign now that they've dropped Jeeves. It mentioned that in the next round of advertising, Ask is going to emphasize their understanding of "concepts" which other search engines can't. For instance, searching for "pimped out cars" will yield results that contain not just those keywords, but other results that also include words like "tight" and "phat."

I also recall how back in the day the big emphasis with Ask Jeeves was in their ability to answer searches posed as normal questions, such as "Where is Fort Knox?" I decided to check out how some Ask results stacked up to Google.





It looks like Ask has managed to provide more relevant results by searching on related queries and displaying them along with other results. The "Narrow Your Search" and "Expand Your Search" sections on the top right of the results page also seemed to contain highly relevant searches that could help you find exactly what you're looking for, and this is a nice feature.

Next I tested the ability to answer questions, a feature that all of the major search engines seem to be trying to solve.






This was by no means exhaustive, and obviously I was picking terms to emphasize the features that Ask has been touting. However, it is interesting to see someone coming up with some more relevant results than Google on some queries. Ask has innovated by searching for related terms, though it'll be interesting to see if this ends up cluttering results with irrelevant entries. They also seem better at recognizing and highlighting answers to questions.

It should be noted that Google has not been stagnant on the search end either. Besides their ongoing algorithm improvements, their OneBox results have gotten a lot better, especially with different tie-ins to travel websites, job listings, and much more.

Submitted by niraj  |  3 comments

More Stories

To reply to a specific comment, find it below.
  • nice
    Posted by: Anonymous on May 3rd, 2006 | 2:44pm

    yeah nice review niraj. Hwoever you must also remember that "It should be noted that Google has not been stagnant on the search" , where google is not only delviery products on search but rather overlaying other products like gmail, hosted services, gbase etc and underlying that in contextual search .

    Ask may return better results, but whats the point of it return "wacky car" when it can't indicate to my if its up for "sale" and where its "located" -- you see where the paradigm is moving.. ??

  • Yahoo
    Posted by: Anonymous on May 12th, 2006 | 11:56am

    Niraj,

    Thanks for your review - very interesting. How do you compare these results to Yahoo? and what do you think of Yahoo search in general?

  • In response to Anonymous
    Posted by: niraj on May 13th, 2006 | 10:27pm

    Anonymous, I am not a big fan of Yahoo search in general because I have always seen less relevant results and their homepage has been a major deterrent for me. (Though you can find a cleaner version at search.yahoo.com)

    I did a quick test with the searches I mentioned in this article, and found that most of the issues I saw with Google were also found in Yahoo's results.